The Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern rail merger
Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern have proposed an approximately $85 billion merger that would create the first transcontinental single U.S. freight railroad. The deal needs approval from the federal Surface Transportation Board, which will weigh its impact on competition and the public interest.
The Powering America Podcast has covered the merger in three episodes: a Sept. 17, 2026, special briefing on growing opposition from state attorneys general, rail workers, agricultural organizations, manufacturers and freight customers; a Sept. 22 interview with Arnav Rao, transportation policy analyst at the Open Markets Institute, on what the deal could mean for shippers and communities; and an Oct. 27 interview with Erik Peinert, assistant professor at Boston University and senior fellow at the American Economic Liberties Project, on competition, labor and supply chains.
Episodes
October 27, 2026
Derailed Competition: The $85B Rail Mega-Merger Threatening US Supply Chains
Erik Peinert, Assistant Professor/Senior Fellow, Boston University
In the latest episode of the Powering America Podcast, host Bryan Hyde speaks with Erik Peinert, an assistant professor at Boston University and senior fellow at the American Economic Liberties Project. They discuss the proposed $85 billion merger between Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern, highlighting concerns about reduced competition, potential negative impacts on labor, and increased shipping costs. The Surface Transportation Board will ultimately decide the merger's fate, with final comments due by November 18.
September 22, 2026
Transportation Analyst Says UP-NS Merger Would Harm Shippers and Communities
Arnav Rao, Transportation Policy Analyst, Open Markets Institute
The proposed Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern merger would harm shippers and communities by consolidating market power and increasing freight traffic, says transportation policy analyst Arnav Rao of the Open Markets Institute. Rao argues that the merger could harm shippers and communities by consolidating market power, increasing freight traffic, and exacerbating issues related to pricing and service reliability. He emphasizes the importance of a strong rail system for industrial growth and environmental sustainability in the United States.
September 17, 2026
SPECIAL BRIEFING: Opposition grows to Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern rail merger
Special briefing
In a special briefing on the Powering America Podcast, host Bryan Hyde discusses growing opposition to the proposed $85 billion merger between Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern. Critics, including state attorneys general, agricultural organizations, and labor unions, argue the merger could reduce competition, increase shipping costs, and threaten jobs, while the companies claim it would enhance service and efficiency. The merger requires approval from the Federal Surface Transportation Board, which will assess its impact on competition and public interest.
Key quotes
“Opposition is growing to the proposed merger of Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern, an approximately $85 billion transaction that would create America's first coast-to-coast freight railroad.”
“State attorneys general, rail workers, agricultural organizations, manufacturers, freight customers, and competing railroads warned that the merger could reduce competition, increase shipping costs, threaten jobs, and leave American businesses with fewer transportation choices.”
“The coalition argues that the transaction would give one railroad control over nearly half of American rail traffic, reduce transportation choices, and weaken the resilience of the national supply chain.”
“The attorneys general argued that the merger is unnecessary and could undermine the competitive and efficient rail service available to American shippers.”
“Opponents fear that combining Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern would reduce those options and give the merged railroad greater control over rates and service.”
“Public opinion may present another challenge for the two railroads, with 55% of likely midterm election voters initially opposed to the merger.”
“A strong rail system is really important for industrial revival.”
“Even if we have a single line service, there's no guarantee that the railroad would pass those efficiencies on to shippers.”
“With trucking, shippers are able to really get a fine-grained, here's where my shipment is, here's when it's coming.”
“Union Pacific accounts for more blocked crossing reports than all of the other Class I railroads combined.”
“Rising fuel costs ostensibly should be a favor for railroads, right? Trucks consume way more fuel than railroads do.”
“Farmers' grain silos really feel the pinch from those increased costs.”
“There is going to be a very large and substantial loss in competition in the railroad market.”
“This merger was exactly the type of thing those guidelines were meant to prohibit.”
“If this merger goes through, it would be the first transcontinental single US railroad.”
“This is something that everybody around this merger knows.”
“At the end of the day, this is offering the employer side of the equation at the bargaining table substantially more economic power.”
“I think this merger should be blocked. Full stop.”
