November 10, 2026 · Institute for Policy Innovation
Unclogging the Pipeline: Why Permitting Delays Are Stalling BEAD Broadband
with Bartlett Cleland, Senior Fellow — Institute for Policy Innovation

Permitting delays are hindering the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program, says Bartlett Cleland, a senior fellow at the Institute for Policy Innovation, in a Powering America Podcast interview with Bryan Hyde. They discuss the critical role of broadband in the economy, the historical context of the BEAD initiative, and the significant permitting delays that are hindering its implementation. Cleland highlights the need for streamlined permitting processes to expedite broadband expansion in underserved communities across the United States.
Related coverage
Unclogging the Pipeline: Why Permitting Delays Are Stalling BEAD Broadband
Permitting Delays Stalling Broadband Expansion Efforts, Expert Says
In a recent episode of the Powering America Podcast, Bartlett Cleland, a senior fellow at the Institute for Policy Innovation, discussed the challenges facing the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program, which aims to expand broadband access across the United States. The program, initiated under the Biden administration, is designed to address the digital divide by providing funding to connect underserved communities. However, delays in local permitting processes are hindering progress.
Cleland, who has over 28 years of experience in technology and public policy, emphasized the critical role broadband plays in modern society. "Virtually everything they're doing... is coming to them over some kind of broadband connection," he said, highlighting that broadband is now the backbone of the economy.
The BEAD program was established to subsidize broadband infrastructure in areas where access is limited. Congress allocated $42 billion to facilitate this effort, which is administered by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA). However, as states await funding to implement their plans, many are frustrated with the slow pace of progress.
According to Cleland, the primary obstacle is the local permitting process. "There are a lot of permits that are required to build out," he explained. A study by the Advanced Communications Law and Policy Institute found that an average broadband project requires between 10 to 20 permits, leading to significant delays. "Each step just lengthens the amount of time until you can put a shovel in the ground," he added.
The permitting process can vary significantly depending on local regulations and the complexity of the project. Cleland noted that municipalities often prioritize their timelines over the urgency expressed in federal legislation, contributing to further delays.
To address these challenges, Cleland suggested several potential solutions. He mentioned that the NTIA could allocate some of the unspent funds to streamline the permitting process by hiring additional reviewers and coordinators. This would help local officials manage the workload without needing to become experts in broadband deployment.
Furthermore, Cleland pointed out that Congress could provide clearer guidelines for federal agencies involved in the permitting process. "They need some clear tools on what to do in these situations," he said, referring to agencies like the Forest Service and the Department of Transportation.
Cleland also highlighted the need for a more efficient approach to managing overlapping jurisdictions. "Some of these permits overlap jurisdictions," he explained, indicating that a coordinated effort could reduce redundancy and expedite approvals.
Despite the challenges, Cleland remains optimistic about the future of broadband expansion. He noted that advancements in technology, such as low Earth orbit satellites, may eventually reduce the costs associated with broadband deployment in remote areas. "It’s going to be less expensive," he predicted, suggesting that competition from new technologies could alleviate some of the financial burdens currently faced by providers.
As the BEAD program continues to evolve, the focus will remain on overcoming the permitting hurdles that have stalled progress. Cleland's insights underscore the importance of efficient regulatory processes in achieving equitable broadband access for all Americans.
The conversation highlighted the need for collaboration between local authorities, state governments, and federal agencies to ensure that the goals of the BEAD program are met in a timely manner. As the digital landscape continues to change, the successful implementation of broadband infrastructure will be crucial for economic growth and community development.
Interview Q&A
Q&A: Unclogging the Pipeline: Why Permitting Delays Are Stalling BEAD Broadband
Unclogging the Pipeline: Why Permitting Delays Are Stalling BEAD Broadband
Q: Who is Bartlett Cleland?
A: Bartlett Cleland is a Senior Fellow at the Institute for Policy Innovation. He has spent nearly 30 years in technology and public policy, working in various roles including Capitol Hill, administration, activist organizations, think tanks, and industry associations.
Q: What does BEAD stand for?
A: BEAD stands for Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment Program.
Q: Why is broadband important?
A: Broadband is crucial as it underpins nearly all online activities, including communication, healthcare, and business operations. It serves as the backbone of the economy.
Q: What is the history behind the BEAD program?
A: Discussions about broadband access date back to the early days of the internet. The Biden administration proposed a program to subsidize broadband access for the 3% to 4% of homes without it, leading to Congress allocating $42 billion for this effort. The National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) is responsible for distributing these funds.
Q: What are the current challenges facing the BEAD program?
A: The primary challenge is local permitting, which involves obtaining numerous permits from various municipalities. This process can significantly delay project implementation.
Q: How many permits are typically required for broadband projects?
A: On average, each broadband project requires about 10 to 20 permits, depending on the complexity and location of the project.
Q: What can be done to streamline the permitting process?
A: The NTIA can allocate funds to hire reviewers or coordinators to manage the permitting process. Additionally, outsourcing expertise could help local officials navigate the complexities of broadband projects.
Q: Are all levels of permitting authority necessary?
A: There is redundancy in the permitting process, with multiple agencies often reviewing the same issues. Streamlining these reviews could reduce delays without sacrificing necessary oversight.
Q: What is the potential impact of excessive permitting on investment?
A: Excessive permitting can deter investment, as the costs associated with legal and regulatory compliance can make projects economically unfeasible. This can lead to fewer jobs and less economic growth.
Q: Is there a timeline for the completion of the BEAD project?
A: The BEAD project has a finite amount of funding, and while it is expected to be completed within a specific timeframe, ongoing technological advancements may lead to future expansions or additional funding requests.
Q: How might technology change the landscape of broadband delivery in the future?
A: Advancements in satellite technology, such as low Earth orbit satellites, may provide competitive alternatives to traditional broadband delivery methods, potentially reducing costs in the long term.
Q: What role does the federal government play in the BEAD program?
A: The federal government, through the NTIA, is responsible for distributing funds and providing guidance on the implementation of the BEAD program, ensuring that broadband access is expanded equitably across communities.
Q: What is the outlook for broadband expansion in rural areas?
A: While challenges remain, there are opportunities for improvement through streamlined permitting and technological advancements that could make broadband more accessible and affordable in rural areas.
Key questions
What is the BEAD program?
BEAD stands for Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment Program, which aims to provide broadband access to underserved communities in the U.S.
Why is broadband important?
Broadband is crucial as it serves as the backbone of the economy, facilitating online activities such as communication, healthcare, and education.
What are the main challenges facing the BEAD program?
The primary challenge is local permitting, which requires numerous approvals from various municipalities, slowing down the implementation process.
How can the permitting process be streamlined?
The NTIA can allocate funds to hire reviewers and coordinators to expedite the permitting process and reduce the burden on local officials.
Is there redundancy in the permitting process?
Yes, there is often redundancy as multiple agencies may review the same project, which can prolong the permitting timeline.
When is the BEAD project expected to be completed?
While there is a finite amount of funding for this round of the BEAD project, it is uncertain if Congress will allocate more funds in the future.
What role does technology play in the future of broadband access?
Advancements in technology, such as low Earth orbit satellites, may make broadband access more affordable and competitive in the future.
Key takeaways
- “The importance of broadband...is that virtually everything they're doing...is coming to them over some kind of broadband connection.”
- “Basically our entire world is running across broadband at some point, if not completely.”
- “Local permitting...is the current hobgoblin...there's a lot of permits that are required to build out.”
- “It turns out you got to go through a lot of levels of review and votes...to get these permits approved.”
- “Too many layers of permitting drives away that investment because it's too expensive.”
- “I think we all kind of want to see investment in our community...but we need permit reform broadly.”
About the guest

Senior Fellow — Institute for Policy Innovation
Bartlett D. Cleland is a research fellow with the Institute for Policy Innovation, where his work focuses on technology, innovation, telecommunications and public policy. An attorney and longtime technology policy expert, Cleland has served on federal advisory bodies, including the Federal Communications Commission’s Consumer Advisory Council, and previously represented the Institute for Policy Innovation on the Internet Safety Technical Task Force established at the request of 49 state attorneys general. He has also worked on technology policy for former U.S. Sen. John Ashcroft and contributed commentary on innovation and regulatory issues for national publications.
Full transcript
Show full transcriptHide transcript
Related episodes
- ‘Why AI Needs the Midwest’ with Bartlett Cleland of the Institute for Policy Innovation
Bartlett Cleland · June 30, 2026
- Why Texas is betting big on data centers, with Garrett Fulce
Garrett Fulce · June 9, 2026
- Debunking Myths About Data Centers with Taxpayers Protection Alliance’s Ross Marchand
Ross Marchand · May 12, 2026
- Polar LNG's role in U.S. energy security, with Joel Riddle
Joel Riddle · April 15, 2026
Filed under
